Comparing Tax Rates of C Corps with S Corps with the Tax Law Changes / Including a Published Article by Frank Cureton with Additional Details of the 20% Deduction

While reading through an article in The Bradford Tax Institute Online Tax Service addressing the question whether a small business owner should switch back to a C Corp now that the maximum tax rate on C Corps is 21%, I decided to blog on this good question, as well as, present additional information on the 20% deduction for pass-through’s as presented by another author. The Bradford article puts all the numbers on the table but basically it proves the true fact that S Corps are still more beneficial for small business owners. If you compare how much tax you would pay on your net business income as a small business owner with an S Corp as compared to a C Corp it still is better than the C Corp even before you apply the highly publicized 20% deduction.

If your income is taxed in a C Corp at 21 % that is great for the Corporation, however, the small business owner needs to get that profit out of the Company. Therefore the business owner would have to distribute the money and be double taxed. An additional tax would have to be paid on that distribution as a dividend at an additional 15%, and possibly, depending on what tax bracket the taxpayer is in, also pay an investment income tax of 3.8%. Now we are up to 39.8%. That is already higher than the maximum individual tax rate of 37%.

So as you can see it is best to stay with your S Corp.

I have been extremely positive about the 20% deduction in many of my posts and it is a fantastic tax savings for most small business owners. In addition, as you can see above, the S Corp remains a better tax entity to operate your business, rather than a standard “Corporation”, as is, even before you consider the 20% deduction.

The remainder of this post is an excerpt from a publication written by Frank Cureton of Haynsworth, Sinkler, Boyd, PA. It gives details on the limitations and exclusions associated with the 20% pass through deduction.

One additional comment before we move into the article below.

An LLC can elect to be a Corporation and simultaneously make an S Election. In plain English, you can be an S Corp for tax filing and legally be an LLC.

Please let me know if you have any questions with that statement, as many people do, or other issues that may arise throughout the year.

The remainder of this post is written by Frank Cureton of Haynsworth, Sinkler and Boyd, P.A.

The key provisions of the new deduction may be summarized as follows:
Types of Entities That May Generate Qualified Business Income.
The 20% deduction applies to business income generated by any business entity other than a C corporation. Accordingly, the deduction will apply for pass-through income from partnerships, limited liability companies that are taxed as partnerships or as disregarded entities, S corporations and even sole proprietorships.

The new deduction may prompt C corporations to consider whether they should convert to S corporation status. There are numerous factors that must be analyzed in connection with such a conversion, but there are two countervailing points in the new tax law that may make C corporation status more attractive. First, the new tax law reduced the maximum rate for C corporations to 21% (down from 35%). The markedly lower rate reduces the impact of double taxation for C corporations that distribute income to their shareholders. Moreover, certain businesses that retain their income might consider converting to C corporation status. Even with the lower rates on pass-through income (potentially 29.6% maximum), a C corporation’s taxable income is taxed only at 21%, unless and until that income is distributed to its shareholders.

Second, the 20% deduction (like most of the individual income tax provisions of the new act) will expire (or “sunset”) after 2025. In other words, beginning in 2026, tax rates on pass-through are scheduled to revert to their pre-2018 levels. Taxpayers considering a change in status must weigh the potentially temporary benefit of the conversion against the costs of the conversion and the costs of a possible second change of status in 2026.

Types of Pass-Through Income That Are Eligible for Deduction.
The 20% deduction applies to any income from a business, so long as that income is effectively connected with the conduct of a United States business. So generally speaking, Section 199A applies to business income generated from operations in the United States.

The deduction does apply to rental income (assuming that the rental operations amount to a business). But the deduction does not apply to certain types of investment income generated by a pass-through entity.

“Qualified business income” generally does not include compensatory payments received by pass-through owners. Consequently, the deduction does not apply to (i) reasonable compensation paid to the taxpayer by any qualified business of the taxpayer for services rendered with respect to the business, (ii) any guaranteed payment paid to a partner (or member) for services rendered with respect to the business, or (iii) to the extent provided in regulations (there are no regulations yet), certain other payments to partners for services rendered with respect to the business.

The exclusion of guaranteed payments may cause partnerships and LLCs to reconsider compensation arrangements with their owners. A guaranteed payment received by a partner will not be eligible for the deduction (and incidentally will decrease the amount of income subject to the deduction). It may be possible for partnerships and LLCs to structure the payment as a priority profits allocation, which may qualify for the deduction.

Limitations Based Upon Type of Business.
Specified Service Businesses. The owners of certain service businesses will only be able to use the deduction if their income does not exceed specified levels. A specified service business is any business involving the performance of services in the fields of health, law, actuarial sciences, accounting, performing arts, consulting, athletics, financial services, brokerage services or any trade or business where the principal asset of such business is the reputation or skill of one or more of its employees or owners.
A taxpayer who receives pass-through income from a specified service business can fully use the 20% deduction if the taxpayer’s taxable income is less than $315,000 (if married) or $157,500 (if single). The deduction phases out as taxable income increases, so that there is no deduction for a taxpayer whose taxable income exceeds $415,000 (if married) or $205,500 (if single). For these purposes, “taxable income” is determined without the 20% deduction.

Other Businesses. Other types of pass-through businesses including non-service businesses (for example, a manufacturing business or even a rental real estate business) can benefit from the 20% deduction. Owners of such pass-through entities can utilize the 20% deduction without regard to their asset or employment levels so long as their taxable income is less than $315,000 (if married) or $157,500 (if single) (with phase-out occurring over the next $100,000 or $50,000 of taxable income).
But such businesses may also use the deduction even when their taxable income exceeds such limits. The owners of such other pass-through businesses may use the deduction up to the greater of (a) 50% of the W-2 wages paid by the business (including to the owners) or (b) the sum of (i) 25% of W-2 wages paid by the business and (ii) 2.5% of the business’s capital (i.e., the unadjusted basis of the depreciable assets of the business). It is the last test (2.5% of unadjusted basis) that allows real estate businesses to benefit from the deduction, even in cases where they have few employees.

In sum, the new 20% pass-through income deduction can add up to big tax savings for business owners and should also prompt businesses to reconsider their business structures to ensure that they are obtaining the most benefit from the new tax law.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *